Thank you for shopping handmade
free domestic shipping

Praise for Tarnished & True Jewelry


I can't stop smiling and love my purchases so much. I will continue giving this shop my business. She is trustworthy, hard working and so talented. I'm in complete awe. Thank you!  -Carmen


I love my ring! It's very well made and fits perfectly! Very fast shipping as well! -Tricia


Thank you so much for the stacking rings you made for my daughter's 18th birthday- I know she will love them and treasure them as they were made especially for her and came all the way from the USA to her tiny village in the UK . Your correspondence and customer service is first class, as is your craftsmanship . It's always great to buy hand made !  -Lesley


My husband purchased these rings for my Christmas present. I loved them!!! The size was off, due to difference in material from what I had, and tarnished and true made the adjustments with no complaints! I would totally recommend them to all my friends...and strangers!  -Juliette


I ordered two of the silver bands and personalized each with my children's names. I wear them with the wild geranium ring. These rings are my new favorite thing! Beautifully made. Love that these are one of a kind and really appreciate the talent in creating them. Shipped quickly and couldn't be happier. Thank you Annie!  -Heather


Love my ring! The fit is perfect and so comfortable. Thanks so much!  -Deb


I absolutely love this ring. It fits perfectly and stacks wonderfully with my other ring. Thank you.  -Nicola


Beautiful perfect ring, so unique and intricately detailed. Shipped quickly. Beautiful packaging. Love it!!! Favorite seller!  -Amy


Beautiful ring!!! My second time to order. My first rings looks brand new and I wear them 24/7.  -B.T


Beautiful! It is exactly how it was pictured.  -Haley


Love this girl! She never fails me & she's always up for my crazy requests <3  -Cheyenne




Very cute ring! Seller very pleasant to work with and she does amazing work! Quick ship and everything's always beautifully packaged! Highly recommended! Gorgeous ring! Seller very pleasant to work with and she does amazing work! Quick ship and everything's always beautifully packaged! -Angela


This piece is absolutely beautiful and the shop owner rushed delivery so my daughter could receive on time. Just love it!  -Natalie


Annie did it again! I love my bracelet. Already have received so many compliments on it. Thank you  -Geri


Beautiful!! Love this store and everyone should order from here!!!  -Kaylan


Very pleased with all my purchases, gorgeous jewelry, timely ship, beautifully packaged, thank you! I'm a repeat customer; I highly recommend this shop!  A.G


I bought a set of stacking rings for my daughter and they arrived today and they were absolutely perfect!! I would definitely order from this seller again and her pieces are absolutely unique and gorgeous. The owner was a pleasure to work with and shipping was fast and turn around was as she stated so the item arrived on time so that I can give this to my daughter for her birthday and I know she is going to loooovvvve it!  -Hope


This is my second set of rings and both are well made and beautiful! 


I am impressed...I am new to stacking rings and ordered one to see the quality, and to decide if they are something I would like, AND I LOVE this ring, and the outstanding quality of the materials and workmanship!! GREAT shop with lovely designs!! I will definitely be buying more! Oh, and the presentation is perfect. I would be proud to send a gift to someone from this shop! Thank you! Smiles.  -H.


Absolutely love my wedding ring. Perfectly matches my stunning Tarnished and True turquoise engagement. It was made up and in my mail box within about ten days. Can't wait to be wearing this special ring everyday. Thank you!  -Siobhan


I asked Annie to set two small stones that I collected from a beach vacation and they are amazing! I love them, thanks! And thanks for being so helpful. -Liz


Bought this ring for my daughter . She loves it an never takes it off. Thanks  -Connie


The very best. I don't wear any other jewelry anymore. Only everything I have bought from Tarnished and True.  -Carmen


I had purchased from Annie before, and I was very happy with my rings. So this time, I went ahead and bought the nine more that I wanted all at once. And, of course, each one is perfect!  -K


These are my favorite earrings! They go with everything and I know I will probably wear them too much. I love knowing that they were handmade. I will definitely be back to purchase more from this lovely shop! :)  -Lynn


Love these rings! I did need to have them resized, but Annie made the process very easy. Will buy from tarnished and true again. 3 wildflowers for my wildflowers.  -Danica


It's my 3rd time I've ordered rings from this seller. Great quality & unique. Love them!! Thanks.  -Eliza


I absolutely love everything about this necklace. It feels great and I appreciate you making it 16" for me. I know I will wear it every day!!! Thank you for your amazing product.  -Dana


I've ordered tons of rings from here and will continue to do so. This is my favorite ring, probably ever!!!  -Jill


My daughter LOVES her rings. I will be a lifetime customer and always come up with jewelry I need from you. All important gifts to friends and family will be coming from your shop. Thank you  -C


The ring I received is amazing craftsmanship! Their customer service is above and beyond! Thanks again Annie!  -Terra


I am extremely happy with my custom order!! Annie is really talented and translated my idea into a gorgeous pendant!!!!  -Cecilia



LOVE IT. Was looking for a piece of initial jewelry that could have both my kids on it. Wanted something unique that showcased my style and this fit the bill. It's different, yet understated and great for daily wear. So happy with it!  -Jodi